| 1 | Philadelphia Union | MLS | Chester, PA | 1900 |
| 2 | Pittsburgh Riverhounds | USL Championship | Bethel Park, PA | 1740 |
| 3 | Steel City FC | USL League Two | Cheswick, PA | 1562 |
| 4 | University of Pittsburgh Panthers | NCAA Division I | Pittsburgh, PA | 1545 |
| 5 | Erie Commodores FC | NPSL | Erie, PA | 1539 |
| 6 | Duquesne University Dukes | NCAA Division I | Pittsburgh, PA | 1510 |
| 7 | University of Pennsylvania Quakers | NCAA Division I | Philadelphia, PA | 1505 |
| 8 | Lehigh Valley United | USL League Two | Bethlehem, PA | 1501 |
| 9 | Philadelphia Union II | MLS Next Pro | Ridley, PA | 1476 |
| 10 | Drexel University Dragons | NCAA Division I | Philadelphia, PA | 1465 |
| 11 | Pennsylvania State University Nittany Lions | NCAA Division I | College, PA | 1462 |
| 12 | Villanova University Wildcats | NCAA Division I | Lower Merion, PA | 1449 |
| 13 | Saint Joseph's University Hawks | NCAA Division I | Philadelphia, PA | 1446 |
| 14 | Bucknell University Bison | NCAA Division I | Lewisburg, PA | 1443 |
| 15 | La Salle University Explorers | NCAA Division I | Philadelphia, PA | 1441 |
| 16 | Robert Morris University Colonials | NCAA Division I | Moon, PA | 1432 |
| 17 | Mercyhurst University Lakers | NCAA Division I | Erie, PA | 1424 |
| 18 | Gannon University Golden Knights | NCAA Division II | Erie, PA | 1424 |
| 19 | Lehigh University Mountain Hawks | NCAA Division I | Bethlehem, PA | 1423 |
| 20 | Reading United AC | USL League Two | Reading, PA | 1419 |
| 21 | WC Predators | APSL | PA | 1407 |
| 22 | West Chester United SC | USL League Two | West Chester, PA | 1405 |
| 23 | Temple University Owls | NCAA Division I | Philadelphia, PA | 1402 |
| 24 | Millersville University of Pennsylvania Marauders | NCAA Division II | Millersville, PA | 1399 |
| 25 | Lafayette College Leopards | NCAA Division I | Easton, PA | 1398 |
| 26 | Pittsburgh Riverhounds 2 | USL League Two | Pittsburgh, PA | 1394 |
| 27 | Messiah University Falcons | NCAA Division III | Grantham, PA | 1394 |
| 28 | East Stroudsburg University of Pennsylvania Warriors | NCAA Division II | East Stroudsburg, PA | 1392 |
| 29 | Alloy Soccer Club | APSL | PA | 1390 |
| 30 | Philadelphia Lone Star FC | UPSL | Philadelphia, PA | 1388 |
| 31 | West Chester University Golden Rams | NCAA Division II | West Chester, PA | 1387 |
| 32 | Capital City Islanders | UPSL | Harrisburg, PA | 1382 |
| 33 | Philadelphia Soccer Club | APSL | PA | 1381 |
| 34 | Carnegie Mellon University Tartans | NCAA Division III | Pittsburgh, PA | 1381 |
| 35 | University of Scranton Royals | NCAA Division III | Scranton, PA | 1380 |
| 36 | Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals | NPSL | Philadelphia, PA | 1378 |
| 37 | Holy Family University Tigers | NCAA Division II | Philadelphia, PA | 1378 |
| 38 | Persepolis United FC | APSL | PA | 1375 |
| 39 | Haverford College Fords | NCAA Division III | Haverford, PA | 1374 |
| 40 | Commonwealth University-Lock Haven Bald Eagles | NCAA Division II | Lock Haven, PA | 1370 |
| 41 | Lebanon Valley College Flying Dutchmen | NCAA Division III | Annville, PA | 1369 |
| 42 | Seton Hill University Griffins | NCAA Division II | Greensburg, PA | 1367 |
| 43 | York County AFC (2026) | The League for Clubs | York, PA | 1366 |
| 44 | Dickinson College Red Devils | NCAA Division III | Carlisle, PA | 1366 |
| 45 | Pennsylvania Classics | UPSL | Manheim, PA | 1366 |
| 46 | Grove City College Wolverines | NCAA Division III | Grove City, PA | 1365 |
| 47 | Pennsylvania Prime FC | UPSL | Allentown, PA | 1364 |
| 48 | Feelsgood FC | APSL | PA | 1359 |
| 49 | Neumann University Knights | NCAA Division III | Aston, PA | 1359 |
| 50 | Point Park University Pioneers | NCAA Division II | Pittsburgh, PA | 1358 |
| 51 | York College of Pennsylvania Spartans | NCAA Division III | York, PA | 1358 |
| 52 | Widener University Pride | NCAA Division III | Chester, PA | 1357 |
| 53 | Philadelphia Heritage SC | APSL | PA | 1356 |
| 54 | GAK | APSL | PA | 1356 |
| 55 | Muhlenberg College Mules | NCAA Division III | Allentown, PA | 1356 |
| 56 | Swarthmore College Garnet | NCAA Division III | Swarthmore, PA | 1356 |
| 57 | Commonwealth University-Bloomsburg Huskies | NCAA Division II | Bloomsburg, PA | 1355 |
| 58 | Lighthouse 1893 SC | APSL | PA | 1355 |
| 59 | Gettysburg College Bullets | NCAA Division III | Gettysburg, PA | 1355 |
| 60 | Ursinus College Bears | NCAA Division III | Collegeville, PA | 1354 |
| 61 | Holger Soccer Club | UPSL | Quakertown, PA | 1353 |
| 62 | Slippery Rock University of Pennsylvania The Rock | NCAA Division II | Slippery Rock, PA | 1352 |
| 63 | Philadelphia Lone Star FC U23 | UPSL | Philadelphia, PA | 1351 |
| 64 | Juniata College Eagles | NCAA Division III | Huntingdon, PA | 1351 |
| 65 | Moravian University Greyhounds | NCAA Division III | Bethlehem, PA | 1350 |
| 66 | Geneva College Golden Tornadoes | NCAA Division III | Beaver Falls, PA | 1345 |
| 67 | Lycoming College Warriors | NCAA Division III | Williamsport, PA | 1345 |
| 68 | Thomas Jefferson University Rams | NCAA Division II | Philadelphia, PA | 1344 |
| 69 | Franklin & Marshall College Diplomats | NCAA Division III | Lancaster, PA | 1344 |
| 70 | Elizabethtown College Blue Jays | NCAA Division III | Elizabethtown, PA | 1343 |
| 71 | Pennsylvania State University, Abington Nittany Lions | NCAA Division III | Abington, PA | 1343 |
| 72 | Pennsylvania State University, Behrend Lions | NCAA Division III | Erie, PA | 1340 |
| 73 | Allegheny College Gators | NCAA Division III | Meadville, PA | 1339 |
| 74 | WC Predators | NPSL | West Chester, PA | 1337 |
| 75 | Arcadia University Knights | NCAA Division III | Glenside, PA | 1335 |
| 76 | Shippensburg University of Pennsylvania Red Raiders | NCAA Division II | Shippensburg, PA | 1334 |
| 77 | Northeast PA FC | UPSL | Scranton, PA | 1332 |
| 78 | King's College Monarchs | NCAA Division III | Wilkes-Barre, PA | 1328 |
| 79 | Pennsylvania Western University, California Vulcans | NCAA Division II | California, PA | 1327 |
| 80 | Misericordia University Cougars | NCAA Division III | Dallas, PA | 1327 |
| 81 | Saint Vincent College Bearcats | NCAA Division III | Latrobe, PA | 1325 |
| 82 | Delaware Valley University Aggies | NCAA Division III | Doylestown, PA | 1322 |
| 83 | Eastern University Eagles | NCAA Division III | St. Davids, PA | 1322 |
| 84 | Mount Aloysius College Mounties | NCAA Division III | Cresson, PA | 1322 |
| 85 | Pennsylvania Prime FC II | UPSL | Allentown, PA | 1321 |
| 86 | Pennsylvania State University, Harrisburg Lions | NCAA Division III | Harrisburg, PA | 1320 |
| 87 | Waynesburg University Yellow Jackets | NCAA Division III | Waynesburg, PA | 1319 |
| 88 | Kensington Soccer Club | UPSL | Philadelphia, PA | 1318 |
| 89 | Northeast PA FC II | UPSL | Scranton, PA | 1315 |
| 90 | DeSales University Bulldogs | NCAA Division III | Center Valley, PA | 1315 |
| 91 | Alvernia University Golden Wolves | NCAA Division III | Reading, PA | 1314 |
| 92 | Chestnut Hill College Griffins | NCAA Division II | Philadelphia, PA | 1313 |
| 93 | Washington & Jefferson College Presidents | NCAA Division III | Washington, PA | 1312 |
| 94 | Westminster College Titans | NCAA Division III | New Wilmington, PA | 1312 |
| 95 | Pennsylvania Classics AC | USL League Two | Lancaster, PA | 1308 |
| 96 | Marywood University Pacers | NCAA Division III | Scranton, PA | 1304 |
| 97 | Susquehanna University River Hawks | NCAA Division III | Selinsgrove, PA | 1304 |
| 98 | La Roche University Redhawks | NCAA Division III | Pittsburgh, PA | 1300 |
| 99 | Vidas United FC | APSL | PA | 1299 |
| 100 | University of Pittsburgh at Greensburg Bobcats | NCAA Division III | Greensburg, PA | 1299 |
| 101 | Albright College Lions | NCAA Division III | Reading, PA | 1296 |
| 102 | Chatham University Cougars | NCAA Division III | Pittsburgh, PA | 1296 |
| 103 | Pennsylvania College of Technology Wildcats | NCAA Division III | Williamsport, PA | 1296 |
| 104 | Lackawanna College Falcons | NCAA Division II | Scranton, PA | 1292 |
| 105 | Lancaster Bible College Chargers | NCAA Division III | Lancaster, PA | 1292 |
| 106 | Cairn University Highlanders | NCAA Division III | Langhorne, PA | 1289 |
| 107 | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown Mountain Cats | NCAA Division II | Johnstown, PA | 1285 |
| 108 | Immaculata University Mighty Macs | NCAA Division III | Immaculata, PA | 1282 |
| 109 | Wilkes University Colonels | NCAA Division III | Wilkes-Barre, PA | 1282 |
| 110 | Thiel College Tomcats | NCAA Division III | Greenville, PA | 1271 |
| 111 | University of Pittsburgh at Bradford Panthers | NCAA Division III | Bradford, PA | 1265 |
| 112 | Keystone College Giants | NCAA Division III | La Plume Township, PA | 1262 |
| 113 | Philadelphia Lone Star FC | USL League Two | Philadelphia, PA | 1247 |
| 114 | Gwynedd Mercy University Griffins | NCAA Division III | Lower Gwynedd Township, PA | 1243 |
| 115 | Pennsylvania State University, Altoona Lions | NCAA Division III | Altoona, PA | 1242 |
| 116 | Wilson College Phoenix | NCAA Division III | Chambersburg, PA | 1232 |
| 117 | Pennsylvania State University, Berks College Nittany Lions | NCAA Division III | Reading, PA | 1230 |
| 118 | Eagle FC | USL League Two | Mechanicsburg, PA | 1198 |
| 119 | Erie Sports Center FC | USL League Two | Erie, PA | 1081 |
| 120 | Hershey FC | NPSL | Derry, PA | 1030 |